Stepbrother Desire (Erotica)

‘Take your pick,’ he thought, lying in his bed. ‘Beth’s angry now over Ashley, and there’s no telling what havoc my walk upstairs has caused with the other girls. I honestly don’t know what I’m gonna do now.’

“Normally, I’d say something to make you go get some pussy, but honestly, I think we’ve had enough embarrassment for one night. I vote you get some sleep, and then tomorrow you can fuck all of them.”

‘Yeah, I think you’re right, for once… about the sleep anyway.’ He turned over and crawled under his sheets, pulling them up to his chest. But sleep would be long in claiming him.

He had really done it. All the events leading up to the last half hour kept replaying themselves in his mind. He’d made love to all four of his sisters. It wasn’t guilt he was feeling, but something different. Maybe an odd sense of accomplishment is what it was.

They all felt different toward him though, and he had a special connection with each of them. He naturally began to wonder what the future held. What if one of them did get pregnant? He knew enough about genetics to know there were risks. Would they keep it? Wouldn’t someone get suspicious about the father? Maybe he should start insisting on wearing a condom.

“Blasphemer!”

He’d have to insist they all go on birth control. Another thought crossed his mind as he lay in the darkness. How was he going to keep all four women pleased? School was starting very soon and he wouldn’t have time to nap after each session, not to mention having to study and actually attend classes. And what the hell was he going to do about Ashley now?

“Fuck her, idiot.”

‘You’re supposed to be sleeping.’

While Ashley did look to be extremely fun in bed, and he’d always heard redheads were, he didn’t harbor any actual feelings for her. He’d known that she’d always had a thing for him as long as Emma and she had been friends. She’d been so eager to please him, it was almost sad. If he wasn’t such an honorable guy, he could probably get her to do whatever the hell he wanted.

“Now you’re seeing things my way.”

Hopefully the rest of the girls visiting would just pass off the nights events as drunken party antics and forget about it. He wondered briefly which one had started rubbing his cock when he’d piled into Megan, Lynn, and Becca. What the hell were they doing out there anyway? He and Beth had been making too much noise, probably.

‘Oh shit,’ he thought, wondering if they’d heard any vocal clues as to who he was actually fucking. He didn’t really hold any hope for them believing it was him just jerking off. That thought struck him as strange, hoping someone thought you were jerking off.

Mike’s thoughts just kept wandering, but finally he drifted off to sleep.

******

Dawn came and glared at him through the window, demanding that he get up and stop all this fucking around in bed. Mike raised the middle finger of one hand flipping off the persistent sun. He just lay there a moment like that, letting his ‘sign language’ do his talking for him, illuminated by the morning light.

Eventually he began to stir and stomped towards the upstairs bathroom. Surprisingly it was empty and he went in, locking the door behind him and showered quickly. Emma was coming out of her room as he finished and headed back towards his room.

“Morning,” she yawned, coming up to give him a hug. He loved how warm and soft she felt, the sound of her breathing, her soft, small but firm breasts pushing into his chest.

‘Stop it,’ he thought to himself, and gave her a quick kiss on the cheek, broke the hug, and headed for his room again. “Morning,” he called behind himself as she turned for the bathroom. He closed his door and got dressed.

Beth was in the kitchen with Sarah and a few of the other girls, all making breakfast smoothies. He grumbled to himself and headed to the cabinet for a bowl of cereal. He’d been hoping for a real breakfast made by Sarah, or even better, Beth.Content bel0ngs to Nôvel(D)r/a/ma.Org.

Beth glanced up at him and looked away quickly. ‘Great,’ he thought, ‘I’ve gotta make some time to talk to her,’ he decided.

“Morning sweetie,” Sarah said, coming over and kissing his forehead.

He nodded curtly and spooned some cereal into his mouth. An uncomfortable silence fell over the kitchen as the rest of the girls entered and spied Mike sitting quietly, shoveling cereal into his mouth.

The stillness of the kitchen was eventually broken by the normal idle chatter. The girls spoke about anything but what had happened last night. Whether out of embarrassment or they just didn’t remember, Mike didn’t know. He was thankful either way. He stood after a few minutes and retreated upstairs.

Sarah leaned against the cabinet chatting with Sally and sipping some of her smoothie.

“So, who snuck into Mike’s room last night?” Lynn asked out of the blue, her gaze scouting around the room. “You guys had to have heard him.”

All the girls turned and looked at Ashley, but she was shaking her head. “It wasn’t me,” she said softly, almost sadly.

“Come on Ash,” insisted Lynn, “you’ve had the itch for him every since we got here, and we all saw you come out of there. On top of that, Mike was naked as a jay bird when he ran into us in the hallway.”

She shook her head again. “Really, it wasn’t me. I went in but he was just pretending to be on his computer.”

“So who was it?” Emma asked with a scowl on her face. Sarah glanced over at her sister, surprised at the tone of her voice.

She seemed to be angry that someone not of their family had been successful in seducing Mike. Sarah tried to pass her a look to cool it before anyone could get wise to the reason for her irritation, but Emma was to intent in finding the guilty party.

“Ash!” Emma glared at her. “It was you, wasn’t it?”

Ashley ignored her, and glanced around the room. Beth had her head down and was doing her best to ignore the conversation. Realization slammed into her and she suddenly understood. It was Beth! It had to be!

‘OH MY GOD!’ she thought. Beth glanced up at her and immediately lowered her gaze. Beth had actually fucked her brother! The thought turned her on and disgusted her at the same time. Her head reeled with the implications, but she began to form an idea in her head, one that would get her exactly what she wanted from Mike.

“ASH!” Emma yelled, crossing her arms.

Ashley finally sat up defiantly and began nodding her head, and then threw a glance back at Beth who finally raised her eyes again. “Yeah, well. Okay, it was me,” the redhead replied.

Sarah put a hand on Emma’s shoulder to calm her down. “Mike’s sex life is none of our business,” she reminded her, giving her shoulder a squeeze for emphasis.

Emma glared back with an ‘are you fucking kidding me’ look, but finally realized the scene she was about to make, and calmed visibly. She glanced over at Danni, who was also glaring, but wisely kept her mouth shut too.

The girls finished their breakfast, continuing the polite banter of the earlier conversation, but the mood had been broken and they began to leave, thanking the sisters for the sleepover.

“We’ll do it again soon,” Sarah told each one as they left.

Emma and Danni were still in the kitchen, but Beth had disappeared. Then, as soon as the last girl was through the door, past the yard and out of ear shot…

“MIKE!!!” all three girls yelled simultaneously.

Mike came downstairs quickly, fearing that a snake had gotten into the house or something. He saw three of his four sisters glaring at him from the kitchen table and immediately got worried. ‘What the hell did I do now?’